Book Review: “The Daughter of Time” by Josephine Tey

The Daughter of Time is a unique and compelling historical mystery novel by Josephine Tey, first published in 1951. The title, derived from an old proverb, suggests that “truth is the daughter of time,” a theme that underpins the novel’s exploration of historical accuracy and the shaping of public perception over time.

Plot Summary:

The novel follows Scotland Yard Inspector Alan Grant, who, while confined to a hospital bed due to a broken leg, becomes fascinated by a portrait of King Richard III. Intrigued by the king’s face, which he finds unexpectedly sensitive and thoughtful, Grant is struck by the dissonance between this image and the popular portrayal of Richard as a ruthless tyrant and the murderer of his nephews, the Princes in the Tower. To pass the time, he embarks on a meticulous investigation into the historical records and testimonies concerning Richard III’s reign, with the help of a few friends and a stack of historical texts.

Themes and Analysis:

Tey’s novel is not just a mystery but a deep exploration of how history is written and remembered. Through Grant’s investigation, Tey questions the validity of historical narratives that have long been accepted as truth. The novel challenges the reader to consider the biases of those who write history and the power of propaganda in shaping collective memory.

One of the central themes of the book is the examination of truth and how easily it can be manipulated by those in power. Tey presents a strong argument that the vilification of Richard III was largely the result of Tudor propaganda, particularly by Thomas More and William Shakespeare, both of whom wrote under the reign of the Tudor monarchs who had a vested interest in legitimising their rule by discrediting Richard. Tey’s reconstruction of Richard III as a victim of history is both compelling and thought-provoking, inviting readers to re-evaluate their understanding of historical events.

Characterisation:

Inspector Alan Grant is an engaging and intelligent protagonist. His persistence in uncovering the truth about Richard III, despite being physically incapacitated, highlights his deep sense of justice and intellectual curiosity. The supporting characters, particularly Brent Carradine, a young American researcher who assists Grant, are also well-drawn and contribute meaningfully to the narrative.

Tey’s portrayal of Richard III, though speculative, is sympathetically rendered. She provides him with a depth and complexity that challenges the one-dimensional villainy often associated with his name.

Writing Style:

Josephine Tey’s writing is crisp, engaging, and laced with wit. She skillfully blends historical research with a narrative that never feels dry or overly academic. The pacing is steady, and the gradual unfolding of the mystery keeps the reader engrossed. Tey’s ability to turn a historical inquiry into a gripping detective story is one of the novel’s greatest strengths.

Conclusion and climax:

The Daughter of Time is a masterful piece of historical fiction that encourages readers to question the reliability of historical “truths” and consider the forces that shape our understanding of the past. Josephine Tey’s novel remains a timeless exploration of how history is written, remembered, and, sometimes, misremembered. It’s a must-read for anyone interested in history, mystery, or the complex interplay between the two.